Core Shamanism and the Western Shamanic Renaissance: Harner, Ingerman, and the Bridge to Indigenous Wisdom

The Return of the Shaman

Something remarkable happened in the last quarter of the twentieth century. Shamanism — the oldest spiritual practice known to humanity, dating back at least 40,000 years — came home to the West. Not as an academic curiosity, not as an exotic import, but as a living practice that thousands and then millions of Westerners began to engage in directly, journeying to non-ordinary reality, working with helping spirits, and experiencing healing that their modern medical and psychological frameworks could not adequately explain.

The two figures most responsible for this return are Michael Harner (1929-2018) and Sandra Ingerman (b. 1950s), whose combined work over five decades has created the most widely practiced form of shamanism in the modern Western world: Core Shamanism. But they are not alone in this movement. Alberto Villoldo, through his Four Winds Society, has brought the specific shamanic traditions of the Andean and Amazonian peoples to a Western audience, creating a parallel stream of Western shamanic practice that shares significant common ground with Core Shamanism while differing in important ways.

Together, these teachers represent a broader phenomenon: the Western world’s rediscovery of its own shamanic heritage, and the complex questions this raises about cultural exchange, spiritual authenticity, and the possibility of genuine healing across cultural boundaries.

What Core Shamanism Is — and What It Is Not

Core Shamanism, as developed by Michael Harner through decades of cross-cultural research, is a system of shamanic practice based on what Harner identified as the universal or near-universal elements found in shamanic traditions around the world. The “core” in Core Shamanism refers to the essential, cross-cultural kernel of shamanic practice — the practices and principles that appear again and again in traditions from Siberia to South America, from Australia to Scandinavia, from Africa to North America.

These core elements include:

• The shamanic journey as the primary method of accessing non-ordinary reality
• The use of monotonous percussion (drumming or rattling) to alter consciousness
• The cosmological framework of three worlds (Lower, Middle, Upper)
• The practice of working with compassionate spirit helpers (power animals, spirit teachers)
• Healing through power retrieval, soul retrieval, extraction of spiritual intrusions, and divination
• The understanding that illness has spiritual causes that require spiritual treatment

What Core Shamanism deliberately excludes are the culture-specific elements of any particular tradition: specific myths, deities, ceremonial forms, costumes, songs, and cosmological details that belong to particular indigenous peoples. It does not teach Shuar healing ceremonies, Siberian reindeer rituals, or Native American vision quests. It teaches the underlying principles and techniques that these and hundreds of other traditions share.

This distinction is crucial for understanding both the power and the controversy of Core Shamanism.

The Cultural Appropriation Debate

The most persistent and legitimate criticism of Core Shamanism — and of Western shamanic practice more broadly — concerns cultural appropriation. This critique has several dimensions.

The Indigenous Perspective

From the perspective of many indigenous peoples, shamanic practices are not “universal techniques” that can be extracted from their cultural context and taught in weekend workshops. They are sacred traditions embedded in specific cultural, linguistic, ecological, and ancestral relationships that have been maintained through centuries of continuous practice and lineage transmission.

When non-native practitioners spend a short time in workshops and then call themselves “shamans” or “medicine people,” indigenous elders often see this as a trivialization of traditions that require years or decades of apprenticeship. The commercialization of sacred practices — charging workshop fees for what indigenous traditions regard as gifts of the spirits — adds another layer of concern.

The term “plastic shaman” has emerged to describe non-indigenous people who appropriate indigenous spiritual practices for personal profit or spiritual authority. Critics like scholar Daniel C. Noel have argued that Core Shamanism, by stripping away cultural specificity, actually homogenizes diverse traditions and lays the groundwork for exploitation by creating a market for “shamanic” experiences without accountability to any tradition.

The Core Shamanism Response

Harner and the Foundation for Shamanic Studies have responded to these critiques in several ways.

First, they argue that Core Shamanism does not borrow specific practices or ceremonies from any indigenous people. It identifies universal human capacities for spiritual experience and teaches people to access those capacities directly. The practices taught are generic precisely because they are universal.

Second, they point out that every human being’s ancestors practiced some form of shamanism. Europeans, Africans, Asians — all had shamanic traditions that were largely suppressed by the spread of organized religions, particularly Christianity. Core Shamanism can be understood as a recovery of ancestral practice for people whose own traditions were destroyed long ago.

Third, the Foundation has devoted significant resources to the preservation and support of indigenous shamanic traditions through its Living Treasures of Shamanism program, which honors and supports indigenous practitioners.

The Ongoing Tension

The truth is that both sides of this debate have valid points, and the tension between them is unlikely to be fully resolved. What is clear is that the conversation itself is important. Western practitioners benefit from engaging seriously with indigenous critiques rather than dismissing them, and indigenous communities benefit from having their concerns heard and respected.

The most thoughtful Western shamanic practitioners navigate this territory by:

• Never claiming to represent any indigenous tradition
• Acknowledging the sources and inspirations for their practice
• Supporting indigenous communities and their struggles for cultural survival
• Maintaining humility about the limitations of their training
• Focusing on their own direct relationship with the spirits rather than claiming cultural authority

Harner and Ingerman: Complementary Visions

While Harner and Ingerman are often discussed together — and indeed Ingerman studied with Harner and served in leadership roles at the Foundation for Shamanic Studies — their contributions are distinct and complementary.

Harner provided the foundational framework: the identification of Core Shamanism’s universal elements, the development of the training methodology, the institutional vehicle of the Foundation, and the key conceptual distinctions (SSC vs. OSC, ordinary reality vs. non-ordinary reality). His approach was that of the anthropologist — systematic, comparative, focused on identifying patterns across cultures. His primary contribution was making the shamanic journey accessible to Westerners through a clear, replicable technique.

Ingerman took the framework and deepened it in two crucial directions. First, she brought the clinical perspective of a licensed therapist to shamanic healing, creating the definitive bridge between soul retrieval and modern trauma psychology. Her articulation of how soul loss maps to dissociation and PTSD gave shamanic healing a theoretical framework that made sense to psychologically sophisticated Westerners. Second, she expanded the scope of shamanic practice from individual healing to planetary healing through her work on Medicine for the Earth, transfiguration, and the Human Web of Light. Where Harner brought shamanism to the West, Ingerman showed the West what shamanism could do — not just for individuals, but for the world.

Villoldo and the Four Winds: A Different Path

Alberto Villoldo’s Four Winds Society represents a different approach to bringing shamanism to the West, and understanding the similarities and differences illuminates the broader landscape of Western shamanic practice.

Similarities with Core Shamanism

Both approaches share fundamental elements:

• An anthropological foundation: both Harner and Villoldo are trained anthropologists who spent decades in field research before developing their teaching frameworks
• A commitment to making shamanic practices accessible to Western practitioners
• Training structures with progressive levels of advancement
• An integration of indigenous wisdom with modern understanding
• Work with helping spirits and the journey into non-ordinary reality

Key Differences

Cultural specificity vs. universality: The most fundamental difference is that Core Shamanism deliberately strips away cultural specificity to identify universal principles, while the Four Winds approach maintains strong connections to specific Andean and Amazonian traditions. Villoldo teaches within a framework that includes the specific cosmology, practices, and initiatory lineage of the Laika — the medicine men and women of the high Andes.

The Luminous Energy Field: Central to Villoldo’s teaching is the concept of the Luminous Energy Field (LEF) — a translucent, multicolored matrix of energy that surrounds and informs the physical body. Villoldo teaches that many physical and psychological problems stem from imprints within this luminous body, and that healing involves clearing and rewriting these imprints. This concept, while consistent with certain shamanic traditions, is not a primary focus of Core Shamanism.

The Medicine Wheel: Villoldo’s teaching centers on a specific Medicine Wheel framework with four cardinal directions, each associated with particular archetypes, healing processes, and levels of consciousness. Core Shamanism does not employ a medicine wheel framework, relying instead on the three-world cosmology.

Neuroscience and nutrition: Villoldo’s more recent work, particularly “One Spirit Medicine” (2015), integrates shamanic practice with neuroscience, nutrition, and practices for upgrading the brain and body. This bridge to biological science represents a different emphasis from Core Shamanism’s focus on journeying and spirit work.

Energy medicine vs. spirit work: While both approaches work with spirits, Villoldo’s teaching places greater emphasis on energy medicine — the direct perception and manipulation of the luminous energy field — while Core Shamanism places greater emphasis on the relationship with helping spirits and the shamanic journey as the primary healing modality.

Complementary Rather Than Competing

These differences are best understood as complementary rather than competing. Both approaches tap into genuine shamanic wisdom, both produce real healing results, and both offer paths for Western practitioners to reconnect with the spiritual dimension of life. Many practitioners study with both traditions and find that each illuminates the other.

The Four Winds approach may appeal to practitioners who resonate with the specific wisdom of the Andean and Amazonian traditions, who are drawn to energy medicine and luminous body work, and who appreciate the integration with modern neuroscience. Core Shamanism may appeal to practitioners who prefer a non-culture-specific approach, who are drawn to the simplicity and universality of the journey method, and who wish to develop their own direct relationships with spirits without the mediation of a specific cultural framework.

The Broader Landscape of Western Shamanic Practice

Harner, Ingerman, and Villoldo are the most prominent figures, but the Western shamanic renaissance includes many other important teachers and approaches:

• Hank Wesselman, who collaborated with Ingerman on “Awakening to the Spirit World” and wrote about his own spontaneous shamanic experiences as a paleoanthropologist
• Sandra Harner (Michael’s wife), a clinical psychologist who brought scientific research methodology to the study of shamanic healing outcomes
• Tom Cowan, who has focused specifically on recovering the shamanic traditions of Celtic and European ancestry
• Christina Pratt, founder of the Last Mask Center, who emphasizes the role of shamanic practice in modern psychological healing

Together, these teachers and many others have created a vibrant, diverse, and growing community of shamanic practitioners in the Western world.

The Scientific Bridge

One of the most significant developments in Western shamanic practice has been the growing dialogue between shamanic practitioners and the scientific community.

Research conducted through the Foundation for Shamanic Studies’ Shamanism and Health Program has examined the immunological and psychological effects of shamanic journeying. A 2014 study published in PMC explored the neurological effects of repetitive drumming with shamanic instructions, finding that the practice induces specific subjective experiences associated with altered states of consciousness.

A scoping review of shamanism as a clinical intervention, published in PMC in 2025, found that shamanic healing has “potential benefits and a relatively low risk of harm” and is “feasible to investigate as a clinical intervention.” While the review noted that the research base remains limited, with only sixteen publications meeting inclusion criteria, it concluded that further investigation is warranted.

This scientific engagement matters because it bridges two ways of knowing. The shamanic practitioner knows the reality of spirits and the efficacy of shamanic healing through direct experience. The scientist requires measurable, replicable data. As these two approaches to knowledge find common ground, the result enriches both: science gains access to phenomena it has long ignored, and shamanic practice gains the credibility needed to integrate with mainstream healthcare.

What Shamanic Practice Offers the Modern World

At a time of unprecedented global crisis — environmental destruction, social fragmentation, mental health epidemics, and existential uncertainty — the return of shamanic practice to the West offers something that no purely material approach can provide: a direct, personal experience of the sacred dimension of reality.

Connection: In a world of atomized individuals and broken communities, shamanic practice offers direct connection — to the spirits, to the web of life, to the ancestors, to the divine ground of being. The shamanic journey is an antidote to the isolation and alienation that characterize modern life.

Meaning: In a world that has largely abandoned religious frameworks without replacing them with anything adequate, shamanic practice offers a framework of meaning rooted not in dogma but in direct experience. The spirits are not articles of faith; they are beings one encounters and with whom one builds real relationships.

Healing: The shamanic framework offers healing modalities — soul retrieval, extraction, power animal retrieval, transfiguration — that address the root spiritual causes of illness rather than merely managing symptoms. For conditions that resist conventional treatment, shamanic approaches may offer relief where nothing else has worked.

Ecological awareness: The shamanic worldview is inherently ecological. It recognizes the earth as alive, the elements as conscious, and all beings as interconnected. This worldview, internalized through practice rather than merely adopted as philosophy, naturally leads to environmental responsibility and care.

Empowerment: The shamanic path teaches that every human being has the capacity to access non-ordinary reality, to communicate with spirits, and to participate in the healing of self and world. This is a profoundly democratic and empowering vision that stands in contrast to spiritual traditions that concentrate power in clergy or institutions.

The Bridge

The work of Harner and Ingerman, complemented by Villoldo and others, has created something unprecedented in human history: a bridge between the ancient shamanic wisdom of indigenous peoples and the modern Western world.

This bridge is imperfect. The cultural appropriation concerns are real and must be taken seriously. The risk of superficiality — of reducing a profound spiritual tradition to a self-help technique — is ever-present. The gap between a weekend workshop and a lifetime of apprenticeship in an indigenous tradition is vast.

And yet the bridge exists, and people are crossing it in both directions. Indigenous practitioners are engaging with Western shamanic practitioners in dialogue and, sometimes, in shared practice. Western practitioners are learning humility, depth, and commitment. And a growing number of people on all sides are recognizing that the survival of shamanic knowledge — in any form, in any culture — is more important than the arguments about who has the right to practice it.

The earth is dying. The soul of humanity is fragmented. The spirits are calling. And the drum is beating.

The question is not whether shamanism belongs in the modern world. It has already returned. The question is whether we have the wisdom and the integrity to receive it well.

A Note on Practice

For those who feel called to explore shamanic practice, the entry point is simple. Michael Harner’s “The Way of the Shaman” remains an excellent introduction. Sandra Ingerman’s “Shamanic Journeying: A Beginner’s Guide” offers a gentle, practical starting point with accompanying drumming audio. The Foundation for Shamanic Studies offers workshops worldwide, both in-person and online. Ingerman’s network of trained teachers, listed at shamanicteachers.com, provides access to experienced practitioners.

But the most important thing is to begin. Find a recording of shamanic drumming. Lie down. Cover your eyes. Set an intention. And let the drum carry you.

The spirits have been waiting for you. They have been waiting for all of us. For a very long time.

---

Sources: Foundation for Shamanic Studies (shamanism.org), sandraingerman.com, shamanism-asia.com, Wikipedia entries on Michael Harner and Neoshamanism, shamanicpractice.org forum on appropriation, Quora discussion on Western shamanism legitimacy, thefourwinds.com, PMC articles on shamanic healing research, Patheos analysis of Harner’s legacy.