Case Study: The Gut That Held the Secret — IBS, Panic Disorder, and the Bidirectional Gut-Brain Axis

Category: Case Studies | All Four Directions | Composite Clinical Case

DISCLAIMER: This is a composite fictional case study based on common clinical patterns observed across integrative and functional medicine practice. It does not represent any single real patient. All names, identifying details, and specific circumstances are invented. The clinical patterns, lab values, treatment protocols, and healing trajectories described reflect well-documented presentations in the literature and are intended for educational purposes.

Presenting Complaint

Mai, a 31-year-old Vietnamese-American woman, presented with a chief complaint of “My stomach is ruining my life.” She described a five-year history of severe IBS-D (irritable bowel syndrome, diarrhea-predominant) characterized by urgent, explosive diarrhea 4-6 times daily, severe abdominal cramping that doubled her over, excessive gas and bloating that began within 20 minutes of eating, and a constant, low-grade nausea that made her dread meals.

The IBS symptoms were accompanied by escalating anxiety. Over the past two years, she had developed panic attacks — episodes of racing heart (140+ bpm), chest tightness, tingling in her hands and face, a sensation of not being able to breathe, and an overwhelming conviction that she was dying or going insane. These attacks occurred 2-3 times weekly, often triggered by the IBS symptoms themselves: the urgency would trigger panic, the panic would worsen the urgency, creating a vicious spiral she described as “my body attacking itself from both ends.”

She had progressively restricted her life to manage the symptoms. She no longer ate at restaurants. She had memorized the location of every bathroom in every building she frequented. She declined social invitations, had stopped dating, and had requested to work from home permanently because a diarrhea episode at the office 18 months ago — “the worst day of my life” — had left her unable to return without panic. She had lost 14 pounds over 18 months, not from intention but from fear of eating.

Previous treatment history: colonoscopy (normal), upper endoscopy (mild gastritis), celiac panel (negative), abdominal CT (normal). Diagnosed with IBS by gastroenterologist, prescribed dicyclomine (anticholinergic — helped cramping mildly but caused brain fog), given a low-FODMAP handout (partially helpful but impossible to sustain long-term), and referred to psychiatry. Psychiatrist diagnosed generalized anxiety disorder with panic disorder, prescribed sertraline 50mg (caused worsened diarrhea — she stopped after two weeks) and then buspirone 10mg twice daily (modest anxiety reduction, no GI improvement). She had tried CBT for 8 sessions (learned breathing techniques that helped during panic attacks but did not reduce their frequency or address the GI symptoms).

She came to the integrative practice saying: “I’ve been told my gut is anxious and my anxiety is in my gut. But nobody seems to know which one is causing the other. I just want my life back.”

History

Medical History

Healthy childhood. No hospitalizations or surgeries. History of recurrent strep throat ages 6-10 (multiple courses of antibiotics — at least 8-10 courses by her parents’ estimate). Mononucleosis at age 16 (moderate severity, missed three weeks of school). Chronic yeast infections in her twenties (treated with fluconazole multiple times). The IBS symptoms began at age 26, approximately six months after a severe bout of food poisoning while traveling in Southeast Asia (acute gastroenteritis lasting 5 days — likely post-infectious IBS, a well-documented phenomenon). The anxiety predated the IBS by several years but dramatically worsened once the GI symptoms began.

Family History

Mother: generalized anxiety disorder (untreated — she refuses to acknowledge it), hypertension. Father: alcohol use disorder (in recovery for 12 years), depression. Maternal grandmother: “nervous stomach” (likely undiagnosed IBS), anxiety. Paternal grandfather: alcoholism, died of liver cirrhosis at 58 in Vietnam. Younger brother: ADHD, marijuana dependence. Family pattern: anxiety runs through the maternal line; addiction through the paternal line. No one in the family had ever been in therapy except Mai.

Mai was born in San Jose, California. Her parents immigrated from Vietnam in 1989. Her father worked as a machinist; her mother was a nail technician. Mai described a chaotic childhood: her father’s drinking dominated the household until she was 19, when he entered recovery. During the drinking years, evenings were unpredictable — “some nights he was charming and funny, other nights he was terrifying.” Her mother managed the chaos through hypervigilance and control: monitoring her father’s moods, managing the household with rigid order, and teaching Mai to “always be ready” for things to go wrong.

Mai earned a degree in graphic design from San Jose State and worked as a UX designer at a mid-size tech company. She was good at her work but found it meaningless. She had a small circle of friends that had shrunk as her IBS worsened. Her last romantic relationship ended two years ago — “he couldn’t handle my bathroom schedule.” She lived alone in a one-bedroom apartment with a cat she described as her “emotional support animal, except she’s not certified and she doesn’t really support me so much as judge me.”

There was something Mai did not disclose during the intake interview. She mentioned that her childhood was “complicated” and changed the subject when asked to elaborate beyond her father’s drinking. She described herself as “someone who had a hard time trusting people” but framed it as a personality trait rather than a response to experience.

Emotional History

Mai presented as intelligent, articulate, self-deprecating, and guarded. She used humor as a deflection mechanism — every time an emotional topic surfaced, she made a joke. She described herself as “the anxious one” as though anxiety were her identity. She reported difficulty sleeping (2-3 hours to fall asleep, frequent waking), constant hypervigilance (“I’m always scanning for what could go wrong”), difficulty relaxing (“my body doesn’t know how to be still”), and a persistent sense of being unsafe that she could not rationally explain.

When asked about anger, she said, “I don’t do anger.” When asked about sadness, she said, “I cry at commercials but not at real things.” When asked about her body, she said, “I hate it. It betrays me every day.”

Spiritual History

Mai described herself as agnostic. Her parents were nominally Buddhist but did not practice. She had no spiritual framework, no contemplative practice, and expressed skepticism about anything “woo.” She said: “I believe in science. If you can’t measure it, I’m not interested.” She acknowledged, when pressed, a deep loneliness that felt existential rather than social — “even when I’m with people, I feel like I’m behind glass.”

Assessment Through Four Directions

Serpent / Ran (South) — Physical Body

Mai’s GI system was in crisis, and the crisis had clear, identifiable biological mechanisms. The post-infectious onset was a critical clue: post-infectious IBS (PI-IBS) occurs in 10-15% of patients following acute gastroenteritis and involves persistent low-grade inflammation, altered gut microbiome, increased intestinal permeability, and mast cell activation in the intestinal mucosa even after the infection resolves (Spiller & Garsed, 2009). The multiple childhood antibiotic courses compounded this by depleting protective commensal bacteria, particularly Lactobacillus and Bifidobacterium species, creating a dysbiotic baseline that the food poisoning then catastrophically disrupted.

The bidirectional gut-brain axis was operating as a self-amplifying feedback loop. The gut was sending danger signals to the brain via the vagus nerve (bottom-up pathway): inflammatory cytokines, bacterial endotoxins crossing a permeable gut barrier, and enteric nervous system activation all drive anxiety, panic, and hypervigilance through neuroinflammatory mechanisms (Mayer et al., 2014). Simultaneously, the brain was sending danger signals to the gut via the sympathetic nervous system (top-down pathway): anxiety and panic activate the HPA axis, increase gut motility, reduce blood flow to the GI tract, increase intestinal permeability, and alter gut microbiome composition through stress-mediated immune changes (Foster & McVey Neufeld, 2013). Each direction amplified the other.

The fact that sertraline worsened her diarrhea was itself informative: serotonin is primarily a gut neurotransmitter (95% of the body’s serotonin is produced in the enterochromaffin cells of the GI tract), and SSRIs increase serotonin availability in the gut, which accelerates motility in serotonin-sensitive individuals.

Her weight loss, fear of eating, and progressive food restriction raised concern for nutritional deficiency, further gut microbiome disruption from inadequate prebiotic fiber intake, and the psychological slide toward avoidant/restrictive food intake disorder (ARFID).

Jaguar / Bao (West) — Emotional Body

The Jaguar direction revealed the deeper architecture beneath the anxiety. Mai’s childhood in an alcoholic household installed a nervous system calibrated for danger. Children of alcoholic parents develop hypervigilance — constant monitoring of the environment for threat cues — because the environment is genuinely unpredictable. This is not anxiety as a disorder; it is anxiety as an adaptive survival response to a chaotic system. The problem is that the adaptation persists long after the environment changes. Mai’s nervous system was still scanning for danger in a world that, by most objective measures, was safe.

In polyvagal theory terms (Porges, 2011), Mai’s autonomic nervous system was stuck in sympathetic activation (fight-or-flight) with intermittent drops into dorsal vagal shutdown (freeze/collapse). The IBS symptoms mapped directly onto these states: sympathetic activation increased gut motility (diarrhea, urgency), while dorsal vagal episodes produced the nausea and the dissociative “not in my body” feeling she sometimes described during panic attacks.

Her relationship to her body — “I hate it; it betrays me” — revealed a fundamental rupture between self and soma. This dissociation from the body is a hallmark of trauma: the body becomes the enemy because it was the site of unbearable experience. The gut, in particular, is the “emotional brain” — the enteric nervous system contains more neurons than the spinal cord and processes emotional information independently of the central nervous system. When the gut “speaks” through symptoms, it is often speaking what the conscious mind cannot.

The undisclosed element — the thing Mai changed the subject about — suggested there was more to the childhood history than an alcoholic father. This clinical intuition would be confirmed at month 3.

Hummingbird / Chim Ruoi (North) — Soul

At the soul level, Mai was living a life organized around avoidance rather than approach. Her world had contracted to the minimum viable existence: work from home, avoid restaurants, avoid social situations, avoid intimacy, avoid risk. This contraction was understandable given her symptoms, but it had created a secondary crisis of meaning. At 31, she saw her life as “a series of things I can’t do.” She had no sense of purpose beyond surviving each day. She had abandoned hobbies (she used to draw and paint), stopped engaging with creative work beyond what her job required, and described her future as “more of this, I guess.”

The soul question for Mai was not “What is my purpose?” — that was too large and too abstract for someone in crisis. The soul question was: “Is a life larger than my symptoms possible?” And underneath that: “Am I allowed to want more?”

Eagle / Dai Bang (East) — Spirit

The Eagle dimension was, for now, closed. Mai’s agnosticism was not a considered philosophical position so much as a defense: if nothing exists beyond the material, then the suffering has no meaning, which is painful — but it also means she does not have to trust anything she cannot control. Trust was the central wound. Her father’s unpredictability had taught her that the universe was not safe, and she had extended that lesson to encompass all of existence. The spiritual work would come later, but it would ultimately be about this: learning to trust that something larger than her vigilance was holding her.

Testing & Diagnosis

Functional Medicine Laboratory Workup

Comprehensive Stool Analysis (GI-MAP):

Elevated calprotectin: 98 mcg/g (normal <50) — intestinal inflammation
Elevated anti-gliadin IgA: 78 (normal <26) — immune reactivity to gluten
Elevated Secretory IgA: 2,840 mcg/mL (optimal 510-2,040) — hyperactive mucosal immune response (consistent with post-infectious immune activation)
Elevated zonulin: 168 ng/mL (optimal <60) — significant intestinal permeability
Severely depleted Lactobacillus species
Severely depleted Bifidobacterium species
Elevated Klebsiella pneumoniae
Elevated Enterobacter cloacae
Elevated Candida albicans — quantitative overgrowth
H. pylori: negative
Parasites: negative
Low short-chain fatty acid production (butyrate markers low — impaired colonocyte nutrition)
Steatocrit elevated: 6.2% (normal <2%) — fat malabsorption
Low Elastase-1: 210 mcg/g (optimal >500) — pancreatic enzyme insufficiency

SIBO Breath Test (Lactulose):

Positive for hydrogen-dominant SIBO — hydrogen peak at 60 minutes with rise of 28 ppm above baseline (positive >20 ppm)
Methane: normal throughout

Interpretation: Post-infectious dysbiosis with SIBO, candida overgrowth, severe intestinal permeability, mucosal immune hyperactivation, fat malabsorption, and impaired digestive enzyme output. This is the biological engine driving the diarrhea, urgency, cramping, and bloating. It is also, via the gut-brain axis, a major driver of the anxiety and panic.

Comprehensive Blood Work:

CBC: WBC 4.8, RBC 4.1, Hgb 12.2 g/dL (low-normal), Hct 36.8%, MCV 89.8 fL
Ferritin: 14 ng/mL (conventional “normal” >12; functional optimal: 50-100) — iron depleted
Vitamin D, 25-OH: 18 ng/mL (optimal: 50-80) — deficient
Vitamin B12: 280 pg/mL (conventional normal >200; functional optimal: 500-1,000) — suboptimal (malabsorption)
Folate: 6.8 ng/mL (low-normal)
RBC Magnesium: 3.8 mg/dL (optimal 5.0-6.5) — significantly depleted
Zinc: 58 mcg/dL (optimal 80-120) — depleted
hs-CRP: 3.2 mg/L (optimal <1.0) — systemic inflammation
Homocysteine: 12.8 umol/L (optimal <8) — methylation impairment
Fasting glucose: 88 mg/dL (normal)
Fasting insulin: 5.2 uIU/mL (normal)
TSH: 2.1 mIU/L (normal)
Free T4: 1.2 ng/dL (normal)
Free T3: 3.0 pg/mL (adequate)
Cortisol, AM: 22.4 mcg/dL (elevated — high end of range 6.2-19.4) — consistent with chronic stress activation

DUTCH Complete (Dried Urine Test for Comprehensive Hormones):

Cortisol: elevated across all time points, particularly morning and afternoon
CAR (Cortisol Awakening Response): exaggerated — 112% rise (normal 50-75%) — characteristic of anxiety states
Cortisol metabolites: elevated total output
DHEA-S: 142 mcg/dL (low for age; optimal 200-350) — pregnenolone steal
Melatonin metabolite (6-OH-melatonin sulfate): low — explains the insomnia

Interpretation: HPA axis in Stage 1 dysfunction — hyperactivation rather than depletion. The system is on high alert: producing excess cortisol, exaggerated CAR, with early DHEA depletion suggesting the adrenal reserve is beginning to strain. Low melatonin production explains the chronic insomnia and feeds back into the cortisol elevation (sleep deprivation perpetuates HPA activation). Multiple nutrient deficiencies reflect malabsorption from SIBO and gut inflammation.

IgG Food Sensitivity Panel:

High reactivity: gluten, cow dairy (casein and whey), eggs, soy
Moderate reactivity: corn, peanuts, cashews
Note: IgG food sensitivity testing has limitations and controversy; results were used as a temporary elimination guide, not as a permanent diagnostic tool

TCM Assessment

Tongue: red body with yellow greasy coat (Damp-Heat in the middle and lower jiao), teeth marks on edges (Spleen Qi deficiency), quivering tongue (internal Wind from Liver) Pulse: wiry and rapid (Liver Qi Stagnation with Heat), weak at the Spleen position Pattern: Liver Qi Stagnation overacting on Spleen (Gan-Pi Bu He), with Damp-Heat accumulation in the Large Intestine and underlying Spleen Qi Deficiency

This TCM pattern is the classical explanation for the gut-brain connection: the Liver (which governs the free flow of Qi and processes emotions, especially anger and frustration) is overacting on the Spleen-Stomach (which governs digestion and transformation). When the Liver is constrained — when emotions are suppressed rather than expressed — it attacks the Spleen, producing diarrhea, cramping, bloating, and anxiety. The treatment must soothe the Liver AND strengthen the Spleen simultaneously.

Somatic Assessment

Hypervigilant posture: shoulders elevated toward ears, forward head posture, shallow rapid breathing (16-18 breaths per minute at rest; optimal is 8-12). Chronic tension in jaw (night-time teeth grinding confirmed), upper trapezius, and iliopsoas (hip flexors — the “fight-or-flight muscle”). Startle response exaggerated — flinched visibly when a door closed in the hallway. Reported chronic lower back pain and hip tightness. When asked to close her eyes during the somatic assessment, she could not — said it made her feel “unsafe.” Interoception (ability to sense internal body states) was paradoxically both heightened (she was hyperaware of gut sensations) and distorted (she interpreted normal gut motility as dangerous).

Treatment Plan

Phase 1: Stabilize the Gut, Calm the Storm (Months 1-3) — Serpent Work

The gut was the entry point because it was the most acute source of suffering and because gut-brain signaling could not be addressed while active SIBO, dysbiosis, and intestinal permeability were driving inflammatory signals to the brain.

SIBO and Dysbiosis Protocol:

Antimicrobial phase (6 weeks): Allicin (garlic extract) 450mg 3x daily + Berberine 500mg 3x daily + Oregano oil 150mg (emulsified) 2x daily (Chedid et al., 2014)
Candida-specific: Caprylic acid 1,000mg 2x daily + Saccharomyces boulardii 500mg 2x daily (S. boulardii has anti-Candida activity and prevents C. difficile while on antimicrobials)
Biofilm disruptor: N-acetyl cysteine (NAC) 600mg 2x daily on empty stomach (biofilm-forming bacteria resist antimicrobials without biofilm disruption)
Prokinetic (to prevent SIBO relapse): Ginger root extract 200mg + Artichoke extract 320mg before bed (supports the migrating motor complex — the “cleaning wave” between meals that is often impaired in SIBO)

Gut Repair (beginning week 3 of antimicrobials):

L-glutamine 5g 2x daily (intestinal mucosal fuel)
Zinc carnosine 75mg 2x daily (gut lining repair; Mahmood et al., 2007)
Deglycyrrhizinated licorice (DGL) 400mg chewed before meals (mucosal protection)
Collagen peptides 15g daily in morning smoothie
Butyrate supplement 600mg 2x daily (compensating for low endogenous production; butyrate is the primary fuel for colonocytes and a potent anti-inflammatory)

Digestive Support:

Comprehensive digestive enzyme with meals (lipase, protease, amylase, HCl) — addressing low elastase and fat malabsorption
Apple cider vinegar 1 tablespoon in water 10 minutes before meals (stimulate endogenous digestive secretions)

Dietary Approach:

Remove: gluten, dairy, eggs, soy, corn (based on IgG panel + clinical correlation; 90-day elimination)
Emphasize: bone broth (1-2 cups daily — collagen, glutamine, glycine for gut repair), well-cooked vegetables (easier on inflamed gut than raw), wild-caught fish, organic poultry, fermented vegetables in small amounts (starting week 4 — sauerkraut, kimchi — introducing slowly)
Low-FODMAP modified: not strict low-FODMAP (too restrictive for her nutritional state) but avoidance of the highest-FODMAP triggers (onion, garlic in raw form, apples, wheat, lactose) during the antimicrobial phase
Meal structure: 3 meals, no snacking (allow 4-5 hours between meals for migrating motor complex to function)
Mindful eating: sit down, no screens, chew 20-30 times per bite (vagal stimulation through mastication)

Nutrient Repletion:

Iron bisglycinate 36mg daily with vitamin C 500mg (malabsorption makes this slow; bisglycinate form is GI-gentle)
Vitamin D3 5,000 IU daily with K2 (MK-7) 100mcg
Methylcobalamin (B12) 5,000mcg sublingual daily
Methylfolate 800mcg daily
Magnesium glycinate 400mg at bedtime (dual purpose: repleting deficiency + calming nervous system + improving sleep)
Zinc picolinate 30mg daily
Omega-3 (EPA/DHA) 2,000mg total daily (anti-inflammatory; specifically EPA has antidepressant and anxiolytic effects at doses >1,000mg; Grosso et al., 2014)

HPA Axis and Sleep:

Phosphatidylserine 400mg at bedtime (modulates cortisol)
L-theanine 200mg at bedtime (promotes alpha-wave activity, calms without sedation)
Magnesium glycinate at bedtime (as above)
Sleep hygiene: no screens 1 hour before bed, bedroom temperature 65-68F, consistent sleep-wake time, morning sunlight exposure within 30 minutes of waking (resets circadian melatonin production)

Vagal Tone Enhancement (Critical — the gut-brain axis bridge):

Cold water face immersion 30 seconds daily (stimulates the dive reflex, activates vagal tone)
Gargling vigorously for 30 seconds 2x daily (vagal stimulation through pharyngeal muscles)
Humming or chanting for 5 minutes daily (vibration of the vocal cords stimulates the vagus nerve)
Slow, paced breathing 5-5-5 pattern (inhale 5 seconds, hold 5 seconds, exhale 5 seconds) for 5 minutes, 3x daily (direct vagal stimulation; Gerritsen & Band, 2018)

Phase 2: The Nervous System and the Unspeakable (Months 2-6) — Jaguar Work

Beginning month 2, once acute GI distress was reducing and Mai had some bandwidth, she began weekly therapy integrating Somatic Experiencing (SE) and EMDR.

Somatic Experiencing — Weeks 1-8:

Focus on developing body awareness without overwhelm. The first sessions were simply about teaching Mai to notice sensations without labeling them as dangerous. “There is a sensation in your belly. It has a quality. It is not an emergency.”
Pendulation: moving attention between a place of tension (gut) and a place of relative ease (hands, feet) to teach the nervous system that it can move between states — that activation is not permanent.
Titration: approaching traumatic material in small, manageable doses rather than flooding. This was essential given the high autonomic reactivity.
Discharge: allowing the body to complete defensive responses (trembling, shaking, sighing, yawning) that had been interrupted during traumatic experiences. Mai experienced significant trembling in her legs during session 4, followed by a sense of calm she described as “foreign.”

Month 3 — The Disclosure: In session 8, while working somatically with the sensation of “something stuck” in her lower belly, Mai disclosed for the first time that she had been sexually abused by an uncle (her father’s brother) between the ages of 8 and 11. The abuse occurred during family gatherings, often while her father was drinking and her mother was managing the chaos. She had never told anyone. She said: “I don’t even know if it counts. He never actually — I mean, it was touching, and once he made me — ” She could not finish the sentence. She dissociated briefly (eyes glazed, voice flattened), and the therapist gently grounded her.

This disclosure reframed the entire clinical picture:

The childhood “anxiety” was not primary anxiety — it was the hypervigilance of a child being abused in a household where no adult was safe enough to tell.
The gut symptoms carried additional meaning: the enteric nervous system stores trauma, and sexual abuse specifically is associated with IBS at rates 2-4 times higher than the general population (Drossman et al., 1995). The gut was not just inflamed — it was holding the unspeakable.
The relationship to the body — “I hate it, it betrays me” — was the voice of a child whose body was violated and who concluded that the body itself was the problem.
The inability to trust, the isolation, the collapsed social world, the avoidance of intimacy — all were downstream consequences of a foundational betrayal by a family member.

EMDR (Eye Movement Desensitization and Reprocessing) — Beginning Month 4:

Following the disclosure and after stabilization work in SE, Mai began EMDR targeting the abuse memories.
Target 1: The first abuse incident (age 8, during a family barbecue). Initial SUDS (Subjective Units of Disturbance): 9/10. Negative cognition: “I am dirty.” Positive cognition target: “What happened to me was not my fault.”
Processing occurred over 4 sessions. Significant abreaction in session 2 — rage surfaced for the first time. Mai had never been angry about the abuse; she had only been ashamed. The anger was a breakthrough.
Target 2: The memory of trying to tell her mother (age 10). She had once started to say something, and her mother had snapped “Don’t make trouble.” Mai internalized this as “What happened to me does not matter.” SUDS: 10/10. This target required 3 sessions.
EMDR for the “bathroom incident” at work (the IBS episode that triggered her social withdrawal). While not a capital-T Trauma, this event had become a traumatic anchor through its coupling with the somatic shame of the abuse. SUDS reduced from 8/10 to 2/10 in a single session.

Boundary and Safety Work (Months 4-6):

Introduced the concept of body sovereignty: “Your body is yours. You decide who touches it, who enters your space, what you eat, when you rest.”
Mai began to practice saying no in low-stakes situations — declining a work meeting, telling a friend she was not available for a call. Each “no” was a reclamation of the agency that had been stolen.
Addressed the family system: the uncle was still present at family gatherings. Mai made the decision — with therapeutic support — to stop attending events where he would be present. This caused family turmoil. Her mother accused her of “breaking the family.” Mai held the boundary.

Phase 3: Reclaiming the Life That Was Stolen (Months 5-8) — Hummingbird Work

As the gut healed and the trauma processing deepened, the soul questions emerged: “Who would I be if I weren’t sick and afraid? What kind of life do I actually want?”

Narrative Therapy:

Mai began to rewrite the story of her life. The old narrative: “I am broken. My body is the enemy. I will never be normal. The best I can hope for is managing my symptoms.” The new narrative, emerging slowly: “I survived something terrible. My body was not the enemy — it was the witness. My symptoms were messages I hadn’t learned to read yet.”
Writing exercise: “Write a letter to your 8-year-old self.” Mai wrote: “I am sorry no one protected you. I am sorry I spent 20 years being angry at our body for what someone else did to it. Our body was never the problem. Our body was the one keeping score when no one else was paying attention.” She read this aloud in session and wept for 30 minutes. The therapist later described this as the pivotal moment in Mai’s treatment.

Creative Reclamation:

Mai had been an artist before the abuse — she had loved drawing and painting as a child, and the creative impulse had been extinguished during the abuse years. She had gone into graphic design as a pragmatic compromise. She began painting again, initially in a trauma-processing context (art therapy) and then on her own. The paintings were visceral, dark, beautiful. She described the experience as “saying what I couldn’t say with words.”
She enrolled in an evening watercolor class — her first social activity outside of work in over a year.

Food Relationship Repair:

As the gut healed, the fear of food needed direct attention. Mai worked with the practitioner on reintroducing foods one by one, pairing each reintroduction with a somatic check: “What does your body tell you about this food? Not your fear — your body.” This practice of distinguishing between fear-based avoidance and genuine intolerance was transformative. She was able to reintroduce many foods she had eliminated out of panic rather than genuine reactivity.
She cooked Vietnamese food for the first time in years — pho, banh xeo, goi cuon — and described the experience as “coming home.”

Phase 4: Learning to Trust the Universe (Months 7-10) — Eagle Work

Mindfulness and Embodiment Practice:

Not meditation in the traditional sense — Mai could not yet sit still with eyes closed in silence, and this was respected rather than pathologized. Instead, she began a body-scan practice: lying down, eyes open, systematically noticing sensations in each body part without judgment. The instruction: “You are not trying to change anything. You are practicing the art of noticing without reacting.”
This practice directly addressed the interoceptive distortion that characterized her IBS-anxiety cycle. By learning to notice gut sensations without panic, she was retraining the brain-gut signaling pathway.

Nature Immersion:

Mai began weekly walks in a redwood park near her home. She described the experience of standing among ancient trees as “the first time I felt like something bigger than me existed, and it wasn’t threatening.” This was not formally spiritual — she would have rejected that framing — but it was the beginning of a capacity to trust something beyond her own hypervigilance.

Community Re-engagement:

Through the watercolor class, Mai made two friends. She attended a dinner at a restaurant for the first time in 18 months. She had a panic moment when she felt urgency — but the urgency passed, and she did not have to leave. She described this evening as “proof that my world doesn’t have to be small.”

Timeline & Progress

Month 1

Began gut antimicrobial protocol and dietary changes
Die-off reaction days 3-7: worsened bloating, fatigue, headache (Herxheimer-type reaction from microbial die-off — expected and managed with increased water intake, activated charcoal 500mg between meals, and Epsom salt baths)
Diarrhea frequency unchanged at 4-5 episodes daily
Began vagal tone exercises — gargling, cold water face immersion, breathing
Sleep: marginally improved with magnesium and L-theanine (falling asleep in 60-90 minutes instead of 2-3 hours)
Panic attacks: 2-3 per week (unchanged)
Weight stable

Month 2

Die-off symptoms resolved by week 5
Diarrhea reducing to 2-3 episodes daily, consistency improving (less watery, less urgent)
Bloating reduced by approximately 50%
Began SE therapy — first two sessions focused on building resource states and body awareness
Vagal tone exercises becoming routine — reported feeling “slightly less wired” in the evenings
Sleep: falling asleep in 45-60 minutes
Panic attacks: 1-2 per week (reduction)
Ferritin recheck: 22 ng/mL (slowly rising)

Month 3

SIBO breath test: negative — cleared
Transitioned from antimicrobials to gut repair and recolonization phase
Diarrhea: 1-2 episodes daily, some days with formed stool (first time in years)
Disclosure of sexual abuse in SE session 8 — this reconfigured the entire treatment plan
Panic attack following disclosure: severe, lasted 45 minutes. Managed with SE grounding techniques and extended session
Sleep disrupted for 2 weeks following disclosure (nightmares, hypervigilance)
Increased magnesium to 600mg, added passionflower extract 500mg at bedtime temporarily
Weight: gained 3 pounds (eating more, less fear of food)

Month 4

Began EMDR — first abuse memory target
Repeat labs: hs-CRP 1.8 mg/L (down from 3.2), vitamin D 32 ng/mL (rising), ferritin 30 ng/mL, B12 420 pg/mL, zinc 72 mcg/dL
GI-MAP partial recheck: zonulin 88 ng/mL (down from 168; improving), calprotectin 52 mcg/g (near normal)
Diarrhea: 0-1 episodes daily; many days with formed stool
Panic attacks: 1 per week, less intense (SUDS 5-6 vs. previous 8-9)
Emotional state: volatile. Rage surfacing in EMDR sessions. Between sessions: irritability, crying spells, vivid dreams. This was reprocessing, not regression — the emotions that had been locked in the gut were moving through the system.
Made decision to stop attending family events where uncle is present
Mother’s reaction: “You are destroying this family.” Mai held the boundary with therapeutic support.

Month 5

EMDR: completed processing of first abuse memory and mother memory. SUDS reduced to 1-2/10 for both targets.
Major shift in gut symptoms: bloating resolving, stool forming consistently, urgency dramatically reduced. Mai said: “I don’t plan my life around bathrooms anymore.”
Began narrative therapy and the letter to her 8-year-old self
Panic attacks: 1 in the entire month, and it resolved in 5 minutes with breathing technique
Sleep: falling asleep in 20-30 minutes, sleeping 7-8 hours with rare waking
Energy significantly improved
Began painting at home

Month 6

Repeat DUTCH: cortisol curve normalizing — morning cortisol 15.8 mcg/dL (down from 22.4), afternoon and evening cortisol reducing. CAR: 62% (normalizing from the exaggerated 112%).
DHEA-S: 188 mcg/dL (improving from 142)
Melatonin metabolite: improving
Full labs: hs-CRP 0.9 mg/L, ferritin 48 ng/mL, vitamin D 48 ng/mL, B12 580 pg/mL, zinc 88 mcg/dL, homocysteine 8.4 umol/L, RBC magnesium 4.6 mg/dL
IBS symptoms: 1-2 episodes of loose stool per week, typically correlated with emotional processing sessions. Otherwise formed, regular, 1-2 bowel movements daily.
Enrolled in watercolor class
Began body-scan mindfulness practice
Anxiety: present but manageable. Described as “a feeling I have sometimes” rather than “who I am.”

Month 7

Painted her first large piece — abstract, dark reds and blacks — and hung it in her apartment. “It’s the ugliest, most beautiful thing I’ve ever made.”
Went to a restaurant with watercolor class friends. Ate pho. Did not panic.
Began reintroducing eliminated foods one by one: eggs tolerated, corn tolerated, dairy — still reactive (bloating, loose stool), gluten — still reactive (bloating, brain fog). Decision: continue avoiding dairy and gluten; reintroduce eggs, corn, soy.
Cooked Vietnamese food at home — described it as an emotional experience
Panic attacks: none this month

Month 8

Mother called and apologized — partially. “I didn’t know what to say. I didn’t want to believe it.” This was not a full reckoning, but it was an opening. Mai processed it in therapy without needing it to be more than it was.
EMDR completed for all identified targets. Residual processing continuing through SE.
Sleep normalized: 7-8 hours, falling asleep within 15-20 minutes, no sleep aids needed (discontinued passionflower)
Weight: regained 10 of the 14 lost pounds — healthy weight restoration
Nature walks becoming a weekly ritual

Month 9

GI-MAP final recheck: calprotectin 28 mcg/g (normal), zonulin 52 ng/mL (near optimal), Lactobacillus and Bifidobacterium species repopulating, Candida undetectable, Klebsiella normalized
SIBO breath test: negative (remained clear)
IBS symptoms: essentially resolved. Occasional loose stool with stress, but self-limiting and not distressing.
Tapered supplements: reduced vitamin D to 2,000 IU maintenance, reduced B12 to 1,000mcg, discontinued butyrate supplement (endogenous production restored), reduced omega-3 to 1,000mg maintenance
Continuing: magnesium, zinc, digestive enzymes with larger meals, probiotic

Month 10

Final comprehensive assessment:
- Ferritin: 62 ng/mL (optimal)
- Vitamin D: 58 ng/mL (optimal)
- hs-CRP: 0.6 mg/L (optimal)
- Homocysteine: 7.2 umol/L (optimal)
- Cortisol AM: 14.2 mcg/dL (normal)
- DHEA-S: 218 mcg/dL (normalizing)
IBS: in full clinical remission
Panic disorder: in remission — no attacks in 3 months
GAD: significantly improved — she described herself as “a person who gets anxious sometimes” rather than “an anxious person”
Social life: three close friends, attending art events, went on a date (“It was weird and wonderful and I didn’t run to the bathroom once”)
Relationship with family: complex but boundaried. Attends selected family events (uncle excluded). Relationship with mother: cautious, evolving.
Painting: completed 12 pieces. Considering applying to a community art show.
Described her healing as: “I thought my gut was the problem. It turns out my gut was the messenger.”

Key Turning Points

Turning Point 1: The SIBO Clearance and Gut Repair (Months 1-3)

The physical gut restoration was the essential first step — not because it was the root cause, but because the biological inflammation was driving neuroinflammatory signaling to the brain that made anxiety and panic physiologically inevitable. You cannot do trauma therapy effectively when the brain is receiving constant inflammatory danger signals from the gut. The Serpent work created the biological conditions for the Jaguar work to succeed.

Turning Point 2: The Disclosure (Month 3)

The revelation of the sexual abuse history transformed the treatment from “managing IBS and anxiety” to “healing the wound that created both.” Without this disclosure, treatment would have plateaued — the gut would have partially healed, the anxiety would have partially reduced, but the core driver would have remained hidden. This turning point could not be forced or rushed; it emerged when Mai’s nervous system felt safe enough (through SE therapy and the therapeutic relationship) to allow the secret to surface.

Turning Point 3: The Rage in EMDR (Month 4)

Mai had never been angry about the abuse — only ashamed. The emergence of rage in EMDR processing was the moment when the emotional charge shifted from self-blame to accurate attribution. The anger said: “This should not have happened to me. I did not deserve this. The responsibility belongs to the person who did this.” This shift from shame to anger to grief to acceptance is the archetypal trauma processing trajectory, and the anger phase is essential — it is the assertion of the self’s right to exist unviolated.

Turning Point 4: The Letter to Her 8-Year-Old Self (Month 5)

This narrative intervention reconnected Mai with the part of herself that had been split off by the abuse. When she wrote “Our body was never the problem. Our body was the one keeping score when no one else was paying attention,” she reframed her entire relationship with her body — from enemy to ally. The gut symptoms, recontextualized, were not evidence of a broken body but evidence of a body that was faithfully recording what the mind could not hold. This is Hummingbird work: rewriting the story that organizes the life.

Turning Point 5: The Restaurant (Month 7)

Eating pho in public without panic was not a small thing. It was the behavioral proof that the world had expanded. The gut was calm, the anxiety was manageable, and the life that had contracted to the space between her apartment and her bathroom had opened again. This moment was the integration of all four directions: the healed gut (Serpent), the processed trauma (Jaguar), the reclaimed story (Hummingbird), and the willingness to trust the moment (Eagle).

Where Single-Direction Treatment Failed

If only the Serpent (physical) had been addressed: The SIBO would have cleared, the dysbiosis would have improved, some symptoms would have reduced. But the underlying autonomic dysregulation driven by unprocessed sexual abuse trauma would have continued to drive gut dysfunction through the top-down gut-brain axis. SIBO relapse rates without addressing the nervous system component approach 45% within 6 months (Pimentel et al., 2006). The gut cannot stay healed when the nervous system keeps sending danger signals.

If only the Jaguar (emotional) had been addressed: Trauma therapy alone, without addressing the active SIBO, intestinal permeability, candida overgrowth, and nutrient deficiencies, would have produced emotional insight while the gut remained in biological crisis. Mayer et al. (2014) demonstrated that gut inflammation drives neuroinflammation independently of psychological state — you can process trauma beautifully while your gut is still sending inflammatory signals to the brain that perpetuate anxiety. Both directions of the axis must be addressed.

If only the Hummingbird (soul) had been addressed: Narrative reframing and meaning-making without the gut healing and trauma processing would have been a form of spiritual bypassing — a beautiful story laid over an unhealed wound. The letter to her 8-year-old self was transformative because it came after the biological stabilization and during active trauma processing. Without that foundation, it would have been a journal exercise, not a turning point.

If only the Eagle (spiritual) had been addressed: Mindfulness practices in a dysregulated nervous system and a body in GI crisis would have been either impossible (she could not sit still, could not close her eyes, could not tolerate silence) or harmful (increasing interoceptive awareness of gut sensations without the capacity to regulate the response to those sensations could worsen the anxiety-IBS cycle). The Eagle work succeeded because it was introduced last, after the foundation was secure.

Lessons & Principles

The gut-brain axis is bidirectional, and treatment must be too. Treating only the gut (bottom-up) or only the brain (top-down) addresses half the loop. IBS with comorbid anxiety requires simultaneous attention to gut biology (microbiome, permeability, SIBO) and nervous system regulation (vagal tone, trauma processing, stress management). This is not integrative medicine as a luxury — it is the minimum viable approach for a bidirectional pathology.
Sexual abuse and IBS are linked by biology, not just psychology. The association between childhood sexual abuse and IBS is among the most robust findings in functional GI research (Drossman et al., 1995; Chitkara et al., 2008). The mechanism is not “it’s all in your head” — it is visceral: trauma alters vagal tone, gut permeability, microbiome composition, mast cell activation, and enteric nervous system function. The gut symptoms are real, biological, and measurable. They are also inseparable from the emotional history that shaped them. Both/and.
Disclosure cannot be forced; it emerges when safety is established. The sexual abuse history did not surface until month 3 — after the therapeutic relationship was established, after the body began to calm, after the Somatic Experiencing work created the internal conditions for the secret to be held. Asking trauma screening questions at intake is important, but many survivors cannot disclose until their nervous system feels safe enough to allow the information to emerge. Clinical patience is not passivity — it is creating the conditions for truth.
The body stores what the mind cannot hold. Mai’s gut was not merely dysfunctional — it was communicating. The urgency, the cramping, the nausea, the diarrhea: these were somatic expressions of experiences that had never been spoken. Bessel van der Kolk’s (2014) axiom — “The body keeps the score” — is not a metaphor. The enteric nervous system processes and stores emotional information, and somatic symptoms are often the body’s only available language for trauma that has not been given words.
Vietnamese family systems complicate trauma disclosure. In Vietnamese culture, family harmony (hoa thuan) and saving face (giu the dien) are paramount values. Disclosing abuse by a family member threatens both. Mai’s mother’s response — “Don’t make trouble” (age 10) and “You are destroying this family” (age 31) — reflects cultural imperatives that prioritize collective stability over individual suffering. Culturally informed treatment does not dismiss these values; it helps the patient navigate between cultural loyalty and personal safety without demanding they choose one over the other.
Healing the relationship with the body is itself therapeutic. Mai’s journey from “I hate my body” to “My body was the one keeping score when no one else was paying attention” was not a cognitive reframe — it was a fundamental relational shift. When the body is re-experienced as ally rather than enemy, the entire somatic landscape changes. Interoceptive signals that previously meant “danger” begin to mean “information.” This shift in body-relationship is, in many trauma cases, the central therapeutic achievement.

References

Chedid, V., et al. (2014). Herbal therapy is equivalent to rifaximin for the treatment of small intestinal bacterial overgrowth. Global Advances in Health and Medicine, 3(3), 16-24.
Chitkara, D. K., et al. (2008). Early life risk factors that contribute to irritable bowel syndrome in adults: A systematic review. American Journal of Gastroenterology, 103(3), 765-774.
Drossman, D. A., et al. (1995). Sexual and physical abuse and gastrointestinal illness: Review and recommendations. Annals of Internal Medicine, 123(10), 782-794.
Foster, J. A., & McVey Neufeld, K.-A. (2013). Gut-brain axis: How the microbiome influences anxiety and depression. Trends in Neurosciences, 36(5), 305-312.
Gerritsen, R. J. S., & Band, G. P. H. (2018). Breath of life: The respiratory vagal stimulation model of contemplative activity. Frontiers in Human Neuroscience, 12, 397.
Grosso, G., et al. (2014). Role of omega-3 fatty acids in the treatment of depressive disorders: A comprehensive meta-analysis of randomized clinical trials. PLoS ONE, 9(5), e96905.
Mahmood, A., et al. (2007). Zinc carnosine, a health food supplement that stabilises small bowel integrity and stimulates gut repair processes. Gut, 56(2), 168-175.
Mayer, E. A., et al. (2014). Gut microbes and the brain: Paradigm shift in neuroscience. Journal of Neuroscience, 34(46), 15490-15496.
Pimentel, M., et al. (2006). Normalization of lactulose breath testing correlates with symptom improvement in irritable bowel syndrome: A double-blind, randomized, placebo-controlled study. American Journal of Gastroenterology, 98(2), 412-419.
Porges, S. W. (2011). The Polyvagal Theory: Neurophysiological Foundations of Emotions, Attachment, Communication, and Self-regulation. W. W. Norton & Company.
Shapiro, F. (2018). Eye Movement Desensitization and Reprocessing (EMDR) Therapy: Basic Principles, Protocols, and Procedures (3rd ed.). Guilford Press.
Spiller, R., & Garsed, K. (2009). Postinfectious irritable bowel syndrome. Gastroenterology, 136(6), 1979-1988.
van der Kolk, B. (2014). The Body Keeps the Score: Brain, Mind, and Body in the Healing of Trauma. Viking.